When I first heard of The Shack, it peaked my interest. But when I heard the criticism from Christian reviewers, I swore it off. A friend, though urged me to read it. I’m very grateful that he did.

First, I would never put this in the hands of an unbeliever and say “Here is everything you need to know about my faith.”, because there are glaring contradictions to our theology. “Papa”, or God, states that Jesus had no power to perform miracles on His own (suggesting that anyone could do what He did if they put their faith in God). This is just one example and a glaring one. And there was the sizable omission of Satan, evil and the way he works to destroy God’s children.

That said, while I read the book from a very cautious point of view, I came to have a deep appreciation for it. I believe a point stated above was a bit condescending, in praying for our maturity. I knowledgeable Christian can read this book, be aware of the red flags, but take the work in its entirety and see great value in it.

The fact that God is depicted as a black woman might appear blasphemous, however he notes over and over that He revealed Himself this way to blow out any preconceived notions that Mack had about God. I do believe the author took this too far when he “Papa” suggested that He is neither man nor woman. Jesus never made any reference to suggest that He is not a “he”.

The Trinity was liberally painted, but I believe the Trinity revealed Himself to Mack as three separate people to meet him on his terms. There was the point that all shared in one being. When Mack spoke to Papa alone, the other two were knowledgeable of the conversation because, “They were there in and with Papa”.

I believe Christians are often too argumentative over non-salvation issues, and press too hard. This can push people away. I will listen to the argument that Jesus’ power to perform miracles Himself is a salvation issue, but we have to ask the question, “Does this book point to the need for our faith to be completely in God, and not ourselves?” I believe this book does this.

The reviewer states: “THE SHACK isn’t really a well-written story. It is told, not shown, which kept me distant from the story.” I believe her bias toward the book tainted her appreciation for the work. I felt it was wonderfully written and did more than draw me close to the players. As a father of three, I was deeply drawn to the story and the characters. I pray that my faith would be strong enough to sustain me under such a tragedy.

I love Jesus and put my faith in Him, and yes, I loved this book.